News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

Woman seeks damages over death of lesbian partner

29 Oct 04

First case of its kind goes to heart of debate on same sex "marriage"

Report praises Incapacity Act

29 Oct 04

Report on the Adults with Incapacity Act finds room for improvement but the Act is meeting its main aims

Anti-Social behaviour provisions in force

29 Oct 04

Key provisions of the Anti-Social Behaviour Act start coming into force

Journal listed for two awards

28 Oct 04

Society's Journal and Editor shortlisted in PPA awards for 2004

Transport Bill published

28 Oct 04

The Executive's Transport (Scotland) Bill has been introduced to the Scottish Parliament

Will Aid set to help needy again

28 Oct 04

Scots can help famine relief in November simply by making a will

Top firms move to cut paperwork

27 Oct 04

Leading commercial practices have produced standard documents for the profession

Victim service extends across Highland

27 Oct 04

Four more sheriff court districts served by VIA

Hewitt wants higher paternity pay

27 Oct 04

Industry Secretary believes new fathers should have 90 per cent of pay on leave

Revenue loses five-a-side appeal

26 Oct 04

Five-a-side football pitches can be "plant" for the purpose of claiming capital allowances

Practice awards for S+ W

26 Oct 04

Scots firm Shepherd+ Wedderburn wins two Practice Management honours

Scots juries not to hear of convictions

26 Oct 04

Home Office promise to allow juries to hear of criminal records will not affect Scotland

Lord Advocate defends COPFS record

26 Oct 04

Prosecution service passes sheriff court target but misses on High Court

Number of drink driving women soars

25 Oct 04

Scots women caught drunk driving reach record levels

Sheriff declines as organist faces music

22 Oct 04

A sheriff declined to sentence a drug dealer he recognised as his church organist

Hi-tech ID parades a hit

22 Oct 04

Virtual identity parades to go live across Scotland following Lothian success

Justice Commissioner's appointment in balance

22 Oct 04

EU Commission President tries to avert civil liberties clash

New network of prosecutors for fishing industry

21 Oct 04

Crown Office sets up specialist team to hook people breaking fisheries law

Profession's money laundering challenge

21 Oct 04

Solicitors' disclosure duties to be tested in appeal court

BBC suspend court documentary

21 Oct 04

BBC Scotland pull documentary on Glasgow Sheriff Court after interdict sought

UK taken to court over duty penalties

21 Oct 04

EU Commission challenges UK customs penalties over "booze cruise" imports

Fair cop, says inspector

21 Oct 04

Crime detection rates are at record levels according to a new report

New tagging scheme for accused

20 Oct 04

An electronic monitoring scheme for those who would otherwise be refused bail is to be piloted next April

Stirling Sheriff retires after 25 years

20 Oct 04

Sheriff Robert Younger is to step down on health grounds

Reliance comes under fire over slashing

20 Oct 04

Slashing of a prisoner in Glasgow casts cloud over Reliance move in Grampian and Highland

Offences specified for vicims' rights

20 Oct 04

Order specifies offences for which victims can be told of offender's release

Majority of offenders breach probation

19 Oct 04

Reports reveal good and bad points of offender services in Glasgow and Scotland

Fresh blow for Reliance

19 Oct 04

Reliance Monitoring Services has lost major electronic tagging contract in England

Planning expert moves to DLA

19 Oct 04

DLA sign up Archibald Campbell & Harley planning partner Sandy Telfer

Surgeon liable for not warning of risk

18 Oct 04

Law Lords uphold medical negligence claim despite causation doubt

Digital sheriff court processes coming?

18 Oct 04

Sheriff Court Rules Council consults on extending IT in civil cases

Scot teaches Moldovans a legal lesson

18 Oct 04

A Scottish fiscal is teaching trial techniques to Moldovan lawyers

Should abuse accused be anonymous?

15 Oct 04

Commissioner suggests current law allowing naming of accused may work against children

Call for corporate killing law

14 Oct 04

Union calls on Scottish Executive to bring in corporate killing law

New appointment for Morton Fraser

14 Oct 04

Joy Barnard has been appointed head of insolvency at Morton Fraser

Glasgow gets domestic abuse court

14 Oct 04

The first dedicated court for domestic abuse launches on Monday

Criminals hit where it hurts

13 Oct 04

£17m of suspect assets frozen in last six months

Support for changes to family law

13 Oct 04

Scots back new rights for cohabiting couples and unmarried fathers

Legal sponsor for Scottish Hockey

11 Oct 04

Shepherd+ Wedderburn agree sponsorship deal for Scottish Hockey Union

Judges get a cutting edge

8 Oct 04

Elizabeth Cutting is the first press officer appointed for Scotland's judges

Revenue relaxes tax disclosure rules

8 Oct 04

Inland Revenue amends tax avoidance disclosure rules to protect legal privilege

Victim advice service for Dunfermline

8 Oct 04

Victim Information and Advice Kirkcaldy service is extended to Dunfermline

Crackdown on internet music theft

8 Oct 04

The UK music industry takes action against illegal filesharing via the internet

Boyd addresses civil law conference

8 Oct 04

Lord Advocate speaks at conference to build up Scottish-Dutch legal relations

1998 guideline reminder

7 Oct 04

Society reminds practitioners of the 1998 guideline regarding proper practice where clients wish to delay concluding missives

Society nails it

7 Oct 04

Fundraising ventures by the Society's staff have raised £6,000 for Children with Leukaemia

APEX honour for Murray

7 Oct 04

Summary of second annual APEX lecture given by Society's President Duncan Murray

Practising certificate fees 2004-05

7 Oct 04

Subscription fees for 2004-05 as approved by the Society's special general meeting in September 2004

IHT changes to affect confirmations

7 Oct 04

Changes to "excepted estates" rules from 1 November 2004 affect applications for confirmation

Lawyer admits fraudulent tax claims

7 Oct 04

Dundee solicitor Louise Hay has admitted a £5,000 child care tax credit fraud

Overcrowding in jails "disgraceful"

7 Oct 04

Chief inspector of prisons condemns current conditions as hampering rehabilitation

Hunters expands into Falkirk

6 Oct 04

Hunters, of the PSM Law Group, is opening a new property shop in Falkirk

Legal IT conference sells out

6 Oct 04

The Law Society's latest Nothing.but.the.Net conference(today) is a sellout success

Call for refuge for justice victims

6 Oct 04

Acquitted pub bomber seeks special help for those wrongly jailed

McGrigors funds Oxford research post

6 Oct 04

McGrigors support research fellowship in tax law at Oxford University

Stronachs' $1bn oil and gas deals

5 Oct 04

Aberdeen firm Stronachs has passed the $1 billion dollar mark for oil and gas deals

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)