News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

CBE for Gerry Brown

31 Dec 04

Convener of Law Society of Scotland's Criminal Law Committee honoured in new year list

Council tax discount changes closer

30 Dec 04

Order laid before Scottish Parliament permitting reduction on discount for second homes

New board members for SLAB

30 Dec 04

Two voluntary sector advisers join Scottish Legal Aid Board

Judges' concern at police warrant failures

23 Dec 04

Woman in racial abuse case escapes sentence after year's delay

Sewage sludge fuel ruled a pollutant

23 Dec 04

Scottish Power stopped from using dried pellets to fire power station

Compensation level for poor legal service raised

22 Dec 04

Maximum compensation for inadequate professional service by solicitors to rise from £1,000 to £5,000

New prostitution laws to protect teens

22 Dec 04

Pornography and prostitution laws to be introduced to protect under 18s

Scots law meets its relatives

22 Dec 04

Scots delegation shares latest ideas at Sri Lanka conference

New planning guidance

22 Dec 04

New planning guidance for conservation areas published

Year's crimes reach one million mark

21 Dec 04

Crime survey estimates that one million crimes were committed in Scotland in 2002

Lawyer sues former firm

20 Dec 04

Solicitor convicted of tax fraud sues former employers for unfair dismissal

New QC appointment procedure

20 Dec 04

Sir Roy Cameron to provide independent report to Ministers

Lawyer takes top IoD post

20 Dec 04

Michael Graham of MacRoberts is new Institute of Directors chairman in Glasgow and West of Scotland

New address was wrong for indictment

17 Dec 04

Appeal court rules police should have left papers at demolition site

Tribunal chairman's "reprehensible" conduct

17 Dec 04

Sheriff in air-rage case attacked for employment tribunal decision

Reliance contract duties broadened

17 Dec 04

Reliance takes over "non-core" prisoner escorts in parts of Scotland

Crime of soliciting to be scrapped?

16 Dec 04

Report proposes new laws to apply equally to prostitutes and clients

Commission seeks views on trustee law

16 Dec 04

Scottish Law Commission's latest discussion paper seeks to simplify the law

Society seeks Scottish solutions

15 Dec 04

Scots assert their independence; English welcome Clementi report

Clementi Report proposes greater competition

15 Dec 04

Report on regulation of legal profession in England and Wales proposes independent regulation and complaints bodies

£460,000 cost of new court

15 Dec 04

Scotland's share of running costs of new UK supreme court to be lower than expected

Journal Online nominated for award

14 Dec 04

Journal website shortlisted for Cuthbert Scottish Legal Awards

Total smoking ban has little support

14 Dec 04

Only 13% of Scots polled support complete ban on smoking in pubs

Chisholm to support third party planning appeals

14 Dec 04

Communities Minister believed to be backing environmental ahead of business interests

Reliance blunder stops trial

14 Dec 04

Judge criticises "administration error" of insufficient guards

"Get tough" approach blamed for jails crisis

13 Dec 04

Report calls for government strategy to cut reliance on prison

Legal aid: paying counsel's fees

13 Dec 04

Guidance on when the Scottish Legal Aid Board will pay counsel direct and when their fees will be assessed as a solicitor's outlay

Victim service extends again

13 Dec 04

Support service opens in Dunoon and Rothesay

Review after Carstairs patient capture

10 Dec 04

There is to be a full review of the rules surrounding unescorted leave at Carstairs

McFadyen takes up new role

10 Dec 04

Norman McFadyen has taken up dual role as Crown Agent and chief executive of COPFS

Police fail to meet crime targets

10 Dec 04

Audit Scotland report shows police failing to stem tide of violent crime

The fallen shall not rise again

9 Dec 04

Fallen action cannot be revived by court dispensing power

New solicitor advocates

8 Dec 04

Three Edinburgh solicitors have received extended rights of audience

OFT launches property search study

8 Dec 04

£200m property search sector to come under scrutiny across the UK

Support for further child protection measures

8 Dec 04

Consultation reveals backing for new internet grooming law

Robbie falls at court hurdles

8 Dec 04

Robbie the Pict's latest challenges to the Skye Bridge tolls and a speeding charge fail before appeal court

710 knives seized by police

8 Dec 04

More than 700 knives have been seized in street crime crackdown

Storm over child porn

8 Dec 04

Charities condemn lawyer's claim that internet access of child pornography is "victimless" crime

Director bound to answer liquidator's questions

7 Dec 04

Court rejects self-incrimination as bar to questions under oath

Egg thief to do bird

7 Dec 04

An egg thief is first to be jailed under new Scots wildlife laws

New chairman for Burness

6 Dec 04

Philip Rodney, the new chairman of Burness,says firm will remain independent

New scheme to treat repeat offenders

6 Dec 04

Justice Minister to unveil training camp plans for repeat offenders

Next President for Law Society

6 Dec 04

Caroline Flanagan will be the next President of the Law Society of Scotland

Scots lawyer wins UK award

6 Dec 04

Stephen Trombala is the UK's assistant of the year

SPS autonomy threatened

3 Dec 04

Justice Minister to announce tighter controls on prison service

Crime pays for Reliance

3 Dec 04

Reliance has reported a rise in profits after overcoming 'teething problems'

Good report for Glenochil Prison

2 Dec 04

Chief inspector praises work to improve conditions

Edinburgh firm honoured for IT project

2 Dec 04

Brodies LLP highly commended for legal IT

Debt arrangement scheme now in force

1 Dec 04

Debt repayment programmes aim to assist people with multiple debts manage their payments

Top judge's anger at MSP

1 Dec 04

Lord Nimmo Smith brands MSP's approach in tobacco case "reprehensible"

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)