News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

Success of High Court reforms

30 Nov 05

Preliminary hearings lead to more pleading guilty earlier

Criminal appeal figures show sharp increase

30 Nov 05

Average time to disposal increases, but backlog now cleared

Police call for minimum term for knife crime

30 Nov 05

Superintendents Association wants mandatory 18 month jail term

Richey back on death row

29 Nov 05

US Supreme Court reverses decision to overturn Kenny Richey's murder conviction

Kilmarnock district fiscal appointed

29 Nov 05

Les Brown is new District Procurator Fiscal

Society calls for independent complaints body

28 Nov 05

Solicitors' body recognises desire for more demonstrably independent system to hear professional service complaints

First full-time managing partner for Miller Samuel

28 Nov 05

Diane Cairney takes up role ahead of firm's planned expansion into Edinburgh

Two DLA Piper partners join Tods Murray

28 Nov 05

Jack Gardiner and Bill Ferrie swell Glasgow office partner numbers

Holyrood focuses on EU legal burden

28 Nov 05

Committee to look how directives are implemented in bid to cut burden on business

Greens look at legal route to air quality

28 Nov 05

Party explores action to force Glasgow City Council to cut pollution

Changes to regulations for Irish law society

25 Nov 05

New rules following OFT investigation will result in "greater competition"

DLA Piper forms dedicated health care team

25 Nov 05

Associate Caroline Stockwell will spearhead health and social care initiative

Housing Bill approved by Parliament

25 Nov 05

Single survey and purchasers' packs on their way by 2007

Lord Hamilton is new Lord President

24 Nov 05

First Minister welcomes appointment of an "outstanding individual"

Emergency deal on legal aid fees

24 Nov 05

Scottish Executive agrees improvements after advocates withdraw

Executive to widen loss of family claims

23 Nov 05

Same-sex partners, grandparents and siblings to win right to seek damages in death actions

Solicitor questions legality of Skye bridge toll

23 Nov 05

Highland Council legal chief says licence "questionable" if it was not signed

Reforms to bankruptcy and diligence published

22 Nov 05

Unified debt recovery system will mean more effective enforcement, says minister

Low takeup of Asbos for under 16s

22 Nov 05

Council leader says children's hearing system needs to adapt to the new law

Executive takes crofting dispute to Land Court

22 Nov 05

Ruling to be given on schemes alleged to frustrate crofting community right to buy

152 teams chase Society debate prize

22 Nov 05

Sixth Law Society of Scotland Donald Dewar Debating Tournament attracts record entry

Harper Macleod launches employer protection scheme

21 Nov 05

Package of legal services and insurance against HR problems "first of its kind in Scotland"

Anderson Strathern appoints head of family law

21 Nov 05

Susan MacLeod joins firm to provide "holistic approach"

Second "big four" firm goes for LLP status

21 Nov 05

Maclay, Murray & Spens signals intent by registering limited liability partnership

New solicitors welcomed by profession

18 Nov 05

Society welcomes 55 new starts at Edinburgh ceremony

Confusion in Scotland over "most wanted" list

18 Nov 05

Police and Crown Office deny failure to co-operate as website goes live

Society's appeal on misconduct finding refused

18 Nov 05

Discipline Tribunal entitled to hold misconduct not established in mortgage reports

Speeding fine quashed after Commission intervenes

18 Nov 05

OAP who could not produce licence allowed fixed penalty level fine

Group recommends new offence of corporate killing

17 Nov 05

Executive to review law on corporate homicide after group's recommendations

Another change to off-licence hours as bill passed

17 Nov 05

Last-minute amendment in parliament cuts off-sale times to 12 hours a day

Lord Cullen orders legal aid case inquiry

17 Nov 05

QC declines legal aid fee and claims Board attempted to postpone case

Error letter did not bar Crown from prosecuting

16 Nov 05

Letter referring to wrong case did not abandon proceedings, appeal court rules

Off-sales hours drama as bill reaches final stage

16 Nov 05

Opposition fears 3am-10pm opening will fuel Scotland's binge drinking culture

New partner for Gillespie Macandrew

15 Nov 05

Christian Melville's appointment takes partner numbers up to 20

Lord McCluskey accuses ministers of interference

15 Nov 05

Judge attacks process of selecting next Lord President

Glasgow joins standard missives club

15 Nov 05

Standard form launches this week to speed up housebuying process

McClure Naismith appoints new IP/IT partner

14 Nov 05

David Gourlay joins from Dundas & Wilson

ECHR threat to change in march rules

14 Nov 05

Councils warn that right of assembly carries more clout than public view of sectarian marches

Orkney legal aid row costs taxpayers thousands

14 Nov 05

PDSO solicitor is flown in after local lawyers pull out of duty solicitor scheme

From the Brussels office

14 Nov 05

Update on changes at the European Court, and the future for contract law in the EU

Direct debits: not the client account

14 Nov 05

Guarantee Fund Committee advice that variable direct debit payments should be set up against an account other than the principal client account

Agents breaking prison rules

14 Nov 05

Some agents have been attempting to enter Kilmarnock Prison on client visits with unauthorised items

CPD goes DVD

14 Nov 05

The first training DVD is available from the Update department for continuing professional development purposes

Prosecutors to swap roles

11 Nov 05

Airdire and Hamilton district procurator fiscals exchange jobs

Environment crime moves up the agenda

11 Nov 05

Scottish Executive looking proposals for specialist environmental court

Sectarian crime figures up following Act

11 Nov 05

Religious aggravation law leads to increase in court cases

Ex-fiscal's stress case thrown out

11 Nov 05

Judge dismisses £120,000 claim for stress at work

Poisoned meal leads to £1.2 million damages

10 Nov 05

Severe arthritis results in payment for lost earnings and care costs

Anti-competitive ruling on private school fees

10 Nov 05

OFT investigation claims exchanges of information resulted in parents paying more

MSP attempts to revive smacking ban proposal

10 Nov 05

Charities back amendment to Family Law Bill

Money still the big issue between genders in law

9 Nov 05

Law Society of Scotland/EOC research reveals wide pay disparity between male and female solicitors

£1.5m savings claim challenged

9 Nov 05

Police chief has "no idea" where Executive got fingerprint savings figure from

Smoking ban's 6am start on 26 March

9 Nov 05

Executive announces exact hour ban starts, along with guidance for enforcement

Legal firm to support charity with learning advice

8 Nov 05

Harper Macleod joins National Autistic Society to provide advocacy service under new Act

Judge reaffirms Crown bail say

8 Nov 05

Sheriff wrong to refuse bail where unopposed by Crown

Public order laws uncosted, say police

8 Nov 05

Police chiefs fear other cuts will be needed when new powers come in

CSA presses for tagging powers

8 Nov 05

Row over whether Agency doing enough to collect child support arrears

Court reform delay questioned in Commons

7 Nov 05

Perth MP wants progress on freeing up legal representation

Management of Offenders Bill approved

7 Nov 05

Bill expected to become law in new year

New equality rules for disabled people

4 Nov 05

In-house Lawyers' Group annual gathering hears of new equality rules for public bodies

Councils get cash for anti-smoking enforcers

4 Nov 05

Executive provides funds for two employees per authority to patrol smoking ban

More than £800,000 awarded for advice projects

3 Nov 05

Scottish Legal Aid Board secures funding for projects to benefit vulnerable people

Accountant in Bankruptcy to move to Kilwinning

3 Nov 05

Agency move is latest part of Executive's policy of government decentralisation

Justice Committee votes to delay divorces

3 Nov 05

Amendment to Family Law Bill would mean compromise separation periods

Civil justice system needs urgent review, says SCC

3 Nov 05

Consumer Council report says public find system too slow, expensive and complex

Fiscal arrested over sex act

3 Nov 05

Senior Glasgow prosecutor caught with vice girl after leaving police function

Senior sheriff to retire

2 Nov 05

Sheriff Albert Sheehan's 46-year legal career ends this month

Law to target those buying sex

2 Nov 05

Soliciting offence to be scrapped by Executive

New bodies to tackle reoffending rates

1 Nov 05

Executive announces eight new Criminal Justice Authorities

Society launches equality and diversity strategy

1 Nov 05

Strategy goes further than the requirements of the Race Relations (Amendment) Act

Fife firms to merge

1 Nov 05

Murray Donald & Caithness joins Drummond Cook & Mackintosh

Council offers free legal advice to staff

1 Nov 05

Glasgow offers to pay for independent advice on equal pay deal if staff reject "no win, no fee" lawyers

Tough new laws for drivers causing death

1 Nov 05

"Causing death by careless driving" to feature in new Road Safety Bill

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)