News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

Sentencing Bill causes storm over early release

30 Nov 06

Criticism over lack of transparency and powers to release low-risk offenders

Prosecution inspectorate report published

30 Nov 06

Second annual report records progress in reviewing race cases and witness services

Late concession offered on Bankruptcy Bill

30 Nov 06

Possible future exemption of homes from land attachment fails to silence critics

Ombudsman upholds free care rights

29 Nov 06

SPSO upholds complaint against waiting list policy

Society's schools debating competition starts

29 Nov 06

Ending use of ASBOs is topic for first round heats

Criminal appeals statistics show fall in cases

28 Nov 06

Completed appeals show 10% decrease in 2005-06

Reporting of race and religion crimes up

28 Nov 06

Figures contrast with decision not to provide similar measure for targeting gay or disabled

Journal advertising - new closing dates

27 Nov 06

Extension follows distribution problems for some subscribers

Delay to Registers of Scotland office move

27 Nov 06

Ministers hold off as ARTL rollout approaches

Property partners for HBJ Gateley Wareing

27 Nov 06

Andy Birrell and Heather Pearson take department partner total to eight

Update head seeks pastures new

24 Nov 06

Iona Ritchie leaves to run own delicatessen business

Number of youth courts set to expand

24 Nov 06

Pilot study of courts in Hamilton and Airdrie says results are "broadly positive"

May elections human rights breach warning

24 Nov 06

QC argues that Scottish parliamentary elections at risk because of prisoner vote ban

Law centre attacks minister over Diligence Bill

24 Nov 06

Wilson accused of "seriously misleading" Enterprise Committee over land attachment

Cheap alcohol and cigarettes ruled out

23 Nov 06

European Court decision upholding tax on online purchases welcomed by retailers

Tougher sanctions for environment crimes

23 Nov 06

Executive seeks views on stricter enforcement of protection laws

Ministers back cigarette-buying age rise

23 Nov 06

Moves to begin to increase legal age from 16 to 18

Child protection bill needs work, MSPs told

23 Nov 06

Proposals concentrate too much on dangers outside the home, say children's groups

More accounting for legislation needed

22 Nov 06

Audit committee hears warning from Auditor-General

Prison inspector warns against sentence reforms

22 Nov 06

Prison population could increase well beyond available spaces in Scottish jails, says McLellan

Highest Scots confiscation order to be issued

22 Nov 06

Businessman to pay back £1.3 million from VAT scam

Strong support for spouse witness law change

21 Nov 06

Historic principle exempting spouses from giving evidence against partners to be looked at

Disabled parking rights to be enforced

21 Nov 06

Proposals to be officially lodged with Holyrood today

Advocates offer free service in needy cases

20 Nov 06

Bar commits to helping deserving cases that do not qualify for legal aid

Lateral hire for Maclay Murray & Spens

20 Nov 06

Firm recruits new commercial litigation partner in London

Rise in community service order breaches

20 Nov 06

Questions asked over resources available to supervise orders

First police complaints commissioner appointed

17 Nov 06

Independent watchdog to take up role from next April

Mother and son admitted together

17 Nov 06

Family pair among 39 new solicitors

New sheriff for Grampian, Highlands and Islands

17 Nov 06

Solicitor advocate and part-time sheriff Andrew Berry appointed

Proceeds of crime provisions civil, says court

17 Nov 06

Appeal judges reject challenge that confiscation a retrospective penalty

Talks over future of "infidelity" provocation

17 Nov 06

Cross-border meeting to review infidelity as plea to reducing a murder charge

Man banned from all UK football matches

17 Nov 06

Airdrie fan gets three-year ban for alleged football violence

Planning Bill passed by parliament

16 Nov 06

Stage 3 vote paves way for royal assent

Holyrood can benefit from Queen's speech: minister

16 Nov 06

Executive to move legislative consent motions to speed reforms

Mitchell appeal to take publicity into account

15 Nov 06

Appeal judges allow one further ground to go to full hearing

Lamont is new Deputy Justice Minister

15 Nov 06

Hugh Henry promoted to education after Peter Peacock resigns

Scholarships up for grabs

15 Nov 06

Offer applies to law and public policy courses at The Robert Gordon University

Narrow backing for Christmas closing bill

14 Nov 06

Not enough evidence that banning shops from opening is beneficial, says opposition

GSPC launches new online service

14 Nov 06

Selling price information for all Scotland available to any solicitor

Drop single survey idea, says Society

13 Nov 06

Property sale questionnaire better than information pack, claims convener

Ombudsman goes public over Society's refusal

13 Nov 06

Newspaper announcements record disagreement over failure to accept recommendations

Protection Bill has MSPs worried

13 Nov 06

Health Committee gives highly qualified backing to vulnerable adults measure

D&W solicitor shortlisted in awards

13 Nov 06

Fiona McKerrell only UK lawyer to make finals of Professional Woman of the Future competition

Prospect of cheap booze

13 Nov 06

Legal ruling could see consumers exempt from paying British tax on goods purchased abroad

SSDT appointments

13 Nov 06

Three new solicitor appointments to Discipline Tribunal

From the Brussels office

13 Nov 06

Update on free movement of lawyers; European Small Claims Procedure; European Payment Order

So you want to be a lawyer?

13 Nov 06

Report of a session encouraging young people from non-traditional backgrounds to consider a career in law

Appointment to Society committees

13 Nov 06

The Law Society of Scotland has agreed a new corporate governance procedure for the appointment of members to its committees

Keep pressing for changes to bill, says Society

10 Nov 06

In house lawyers' annual gathering to discuss Legal Profession etc Bill

Proposal to make crime story profiteering a crime

10 Nov 06

UK-wide consultation looks at options to prevent criminals benefiting from publishing sales

Drummond Miller converts to LLP

10 Nov 06

Eight-branch firm cites transparency as its main reason for conversion

Major consultation on legal education opens today

9 Nov 06

Society calls on lawyers and non-lawyers to join in online survey

Two partner appointments for north east firm

9 Nov 06

Paull & Williamsons promote commercial property and employment law specialists

Digby Brown dance raises £38,000 for charity

9 Nov 06

Anual event raises best total yet for Spinal Injuries Scotland

Transsexuals getting state pension at 60

9 Nov 06

DWP statement recognises legal status of males-to-females as women

Complaints body still not ECHR-compliant: Lester

8 Nov 06

Society publishes opinion that amended bill still beyond parliament's comptence

MSPs' allowances under review

8 Nov 06

Announcement of shake-up follows complaints of property profiteering

Concern over drop in volunteer numbers

8 Nov 06

Greater disclosure requirements mean fewer helpers, group tells MSPs

Solicitor drug bribe report to be investigated

7 Nov 06

Allegations of cash inducements to sign legal aid forms

Parking fines may have been issued illegally

7 Nov 06

Adjudicator's ruling on off-street car parks causes surprise

In-house moves to avoid court - survey

7 Nov 06

Resources shift to dispute avoidance could leave external advisers in the cold

Sentence reform costs warning

6 Nov 06

Councils and social worker chiefs fear massive social work costs increase

In-house lawyers' top event this week

6 Nov 06

Big name speakers for annual conference and dinner

First Minister backing for paedophile disclosure

6 Nov 06

McConnell's U-turn follows example of Californian system

Associate promotions for Semple Fraser

6 Nov 06

Recognition for Stacey Smyth, Claire McPherson and Alix Wotherspoon

Associate hire for HBJ Gateley Wareing

3 Nov 06

James Aitken joins firm's Edinburgh office

Strong challenge by Journal in magazine awards

3 Nov 06

Society's magazine makes four category shortlists for PPA Scotland awards

Coulsfield to review criminal evidence disclosure

3 Nov 06

Executive seeks balance between duty to disclose and witness protection

Edinburgh launch of collaborative family law

3 Nov 06

Scottish group for lawyers aiming to reduce trauma of divorce

New human rights body given green light

3 Nov 06

Commission proposals approved by Holyrood in amended form

Report calls for Crown Estate to be devolved

3 Nov 06

Scottish Executive should take control of country's foreshore and seabed

Marriage to stepdaughter annulled

3 Nov 06

"Archaic" law overturns marriage after sister reports case to registrar's office

Cuthbert awards forced to move

2 Nov 06

EICC booking problem puts ceremony back three weeks

Time bar waived for soldier's claim

2 Nov 06

Solicitors' error not fatal when second action proceeding

VIA to prioritise religious crime victims

2 Nov 06

Automatic referrals for victims where religious aggravation alleged

SDLT e-certificates go live

2 Nov 06

Scots solicitors quick off their marks in printing own certificates

Lockerbie sentence appeal to be heard in Scotland

1 Nov 06

Judges rule that Megrahi tariff appeal need not be heard in the Netherlands

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)