News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

Solicitors wanted for Will Relief 2007

31 Oct 07

Scheme founder urges more to sign up for charity initiative

Fixed penalties proposed for planning breaches

31 Oct 07

Councils feel prosecutions are too lengthy and expensive

Sunbed ban for children coming

31 Oct 07

Government to include restrictions on sunbed use as part of Public Health Bill

Man walks free after collapse of child sex trial

31 Oct 07

Crown Office blamed for wrongly worded charges in Alloa case

Ferguson revives Property Factors Bill

30 Oct 07

Consultation now running on proposals for registration and dispute resolution

Councils breaching Data Protection Act

30 Oct 07

Online planning applications display too much personal information

Late returns charities named and shamed

30 Oct 07

New list on website highlights voluntary bodies not complying with legislation

MacAskill wants traffic law change

29 Oct 07

Scottish Government requests amendments to legislation to free up police time

Top manager appointment at Lindsays

29 Oct 07

Brodies' finance director poached as chief operating officer

Tennis doubles challenge

29 Oct 07

Law firms battle it out for title in fund-raising event

Ian Smart elected Society Vice President

26 Oct 07

Cumbernauld lawyer will serve until May 2009

Public Health Bill unveiled

26 Oct 07

Bill will update law on infectious diseases and contamination

Parliament offers Brussels briefings

26 Oct 07

Fortnightly updates on key dossiers

Ministers to review antisocial behaviour controls

25 Oct 07

Prevention-enforcement balance among points of focus

Privatisation limits information access: Dunion

25 Oct 07

Information Commissioner wants legislation extended to safeguard public money

Lords' ruling extends reach of slopping out cases

25 Oct 07

Human rights claims against Scottish ministers not subject to 12 month time limit

Edinburgh infirmary PFI contract must be disclosed

24 Oct 07

Information Commissioner rejects claim of confidentiality for lack of support

Siddique lawyer under threat of contempt charge

24 Oct 07

Judge considering remarks said to misrepresent trial outcome

Graduate Endowment Abolition Bill published

23 Oct 07

Bill will extinguish liabilities falling due after 1 April 2008

Prisons Commission members announced

23 Oct 07

First meeting of eight-strong review group takes place tomorrow

Law Lords uphold parking servitude right

23 Oct 07

Nine year battle ends in victory for access right holders

HQ growth for Aberdeen firm

23 Oct 07

Raeburn Christie Clark & Wallace in two stage expansion plan

Zimbabwe Law Society President seeks UK support

22 Oct 07

Society's report details abuses suffered by lawyers for defending rule of law

Specialist sex offences team for south east

22 Oct 07

"Amethyst" unit to improve coordination between police and Crown in Lothian and Borders

Two specialists join McClure Naismith

22 Oct 07

David Montague joins firm's London office, while Thomas Morrison starts in Edinburgh

New IT system for Victim Support

19 Oct 07

Toolkit will allow more tailored services for victims of crime

Taskforce to tackle 'cancer' of organised crime

19 Oct 07

Government body brings together different crime-fighting experts

Advocates move to Glasgow

18 Oct 07

Mackinnon stable heads west to deal with city's high number of criminal cases

No compensation for pleural plaques sufferers

17 Oct 07

Law Lords exclude asbestos-related condition from insurance firm pay-outs

Councils not obliged to pay for personal care

17 Oct 07

Lord Macphail overturns ruling ordering council to pay for elderly man's care

Four new advocate deputes

15 Oct 07

New appointees will take total to 27 by the end of October

New act targets kerb crawlers

15 Oct 07

But campaigners worried about consequences of ending prostitution tolerance zone

Society launches strategy for would-be lawyers

15 Oct 07

Initiative aimed at supporting students and trainees

Society to look out for late PC renewals

15 Oct 07

A note of the subscription fees for 2007-08, and a warning that late renewal of practising certificates may be treated as professional misconduct

OISC and solicitors' files

15 Oct 07

The Society's obligations to the Immigration Services Commissioner when she is investigating complaints

IHT procedure changes

15 Oct 07

New process from 5 November 2007 for making an initial payment of inheritance tax by cheque

Lord Advocate addresses French conference

12 Oct 07

Guest speaker at Cour de Cassation event on future of the public prosecutor

Court rules against supported placing request

12 Oct 07

Act makes no provision for request to another local authority, say appeal judges

National rape helpline launched

12 Oct 07

365-day freephone service for those affected by sexual violence

Law firm organises green initiative

11 Oct 07

National Green Day to promote sustainability to primary and secondary schools

Cheating lawyer fined £10,000

11 Oct 07

But Paul Kirk will not face prosecution for legal aid overcharging

Court lays down rules on dock ID

10 Oct 07

No rule that witness must always be asked to identify accused directly, say appeal judges

Group seek Lord Advocate's intervention on Trident

9 Oct 07

Opinion sought by campaigners including former Lord Advocate Lord Murray

Legal sector says go for green

8 Oct 07

Law Society of England and Wales in initiative to promote sustainability

Two join McGrigors from DLA Piper

8 Oct 07

Ian McCarlie and Shannon Rousson join firm's energy team

Patrick Bell joins Shepherd and Wedderburn

8 Oct 07

Partner appointment for finance lawyer as nine promoted to associate

Government seeks views on whisky legislation

8 Oct 07

New rules proposed to increase protection against imitation brands

Review of wildlife crime prosecution

5 Oct 07

Environment Minister announces move that will also look at the investigation of such crimes

Stolen painting turns up in law office

5 Oct 07

Da Vinci's Madonna recovered as firm insists arrested lawyer was acting properly

Lateral hires for Brodies

5 Oct 07

Two partners join firm from DLA Piper

Step up for company lawyer

4 Oct 07

Murray International Holdings' David Horne joins company board

Defective records bar partnership claim

4 Oct 07

Legal firm fails against former partner due to inability to value work

Drop in numbers released on parole

4 Oct 07

Parole Board for Scotland's work continues at busy level, says annual report

Angiolini and Hamilton agree on independence

4 Oct 07

Lord Advocate and Lord Justice General meet over parliament statement

Conflict of interest waivers

4 Oct 07

Supporting evidence that will be required with any conflict of interest waiver application in relation to provisions of the Companies Act 2006

Driver rules relaxed to tackle animal backlog

3 Oct 07

Truckers can spend more time on the roads to transport animals following foot-and-mouth crisis

Bail set at $10 million for Richey

3 Oct 07

Scot in US jail will need to raise 10% of sum to be freed

£1.8m legal aid fraud to be repaid

3 Oct 07

SLAB report reveals that money will be paid back by January 2008

Lord Advocate's meeting request with Lord Hamilton

2 Oct 07

Meeting intended to clear the air after public spat

Justice Secretary snubbed by London

2 Oct 07

UK ministers take all places at EU legal meeting despite claims of Scots law

Commissioner orders release of witness statements

1 Oct 07

Balance of public interest shifts over unsolved 1912 murder, says Dunion

Summary criminal legal aid up for reform

1 Oct 07

Scottish Legal Aid Board consultation paper proposes better early fees

SLAB reports rise in legal aid grants

1 Oct 07

Scottish Legal Aid Board publishes annual report for 2006-07

Two join HBJ Gateley Wareing from Harper Macleod

1 Oct 07

Partner and associate will make up new specialist team

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)