News In Focus

8 February 2012

Bail law held ultra vires

A provision in the Scottish Parliament's Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 has been held outwith its powers by the criminal appeal court in Edinburgh.

Three judges ruled that s58 of the Act, which makes it a condition of an accused being given bail that they take part in an identification parade, or allow a print, impression or sample to be taken from them, whenever reasonably instructed by a constable to do so, infringes article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights and is therefore not law, in terms of the Scotland Act.

Before s58, it was up to the court or the Lord Advocate to impose additional conditions as they considered necessary to ensure that the accused took part in thses procedures.

The court accepted an argument that to complpy with article 5 (the right to liberty), bail conditions required to relate to a matter which would otherwise justify detention. Bail conditions, as with any decision to detain pending trial, required to be specifically related to the circumstances of the particular case and to be determined judicially according to those circumstances.

The Government's justification for introducing the change was that it would free up court time - a reason the Crown found it difficult to defend at the hearing. (It also admitted that the position prior to the amendment had not been satisfactory.)

Although the Crown tried to argue that article 5 was not engaged - in that it was concerned with actual detention and not release on conditions - the court pointed out that textually, article 5(3) referred to conditions of release from pre-trial detention, which, it added, was naturally interlinked with the right to liberty pending trial.

"The fundamental problem presented in this appeal", said Lord Eassie, delivering the court's opinion, "is that the amendment to section 24 of the 1995 Act which was effected by section 58 of the 2010 Act removes the opportunity for any individual consideration by a judge of whether detention might otherwise be necessary for the purposes to which the amended section 24(5)(cb) refers and thus any individual case consideration of whether that perceived necessity for short term detention might be met by a suitable condition."

Click here to view the court's opinion.


Have your say





News reel

Discipline Tribunal appointments

31 Oct 08

Five non-lawyer members announced

Megrahi could be freed on bail within a week

31 Oct 08

Convicted Lockerbie bomber's medical reports sent to appeal court

Conference marks 60th anniversary of human rights

31 Oct 08

Glasgow venue for joint SHRC and University of Strathclyde event

Bell & Scott announce new managing partner

31 Oct 08

Paul Jennings to succeed Iain MacDonald

Solicitors' guideline on house settlements revised

30 Oct 08

Society issues amended views on payment by cheque and CHAPS transfer

MSP to launch assisted suicide consultation

30 Oct 08

Margo MacDonald seeks views on changing the law to allow choice

Call for tougher sanctions for data breaches

30 Oct 08

UK Information Commissioner warns that large databases are 'toxic assets'

Public procurement service launched

29 Oct 08

Portal aimed at making it easier to bid for public service contracts

Session Cases publishers launch website

29 Oct 08

Selected cases available free to public

Edinburgh property market feels the pinch

29 Oct 08

Downturn sees the first drop in prices in 37 years

Banks begin appeal against OFT investigation

29 Oct 08

Challenge to ruling that OFT can look into fairness of overdraft charges

Planning reforms announced

28 Oct 08

Separate planning policies to be streamlined into one

Four public schools fail charity test standard

28 Oct 08

Regulator publishes first results of rolling review under 2005 Act

Scottish Government seeks to outbid London on climate change

28 Oct 08

Bill to include international aviation and shipping as well as annual targets

Legal director for DLA Piper

27 Oct 08

Firm welcomes Duncan Mawby to its insurance team

Reid appointed to Edinburgh Scots Law chair

27 Oct 08

Leading property lawyer becomes 17th holder

Charities warned against "drift to commercialism"

27 Oct 08

Keynote speech by Lord Phillips says banking crisis is a wakeup call

Joint runner-up innovation award for MMS

27 Oct 08

Law firm awarded standout status for its KnowlEDGE campaign

Youngsters to debate the Paisley snail case in court

24 Oct 08

Faculty of Advocates' scheme encourages would-be young lawyers

Scots not better protected against repossession, says GLC

24 Oct 08

Scottish Government urged to tighten law so eviction is last resort

Law firm supports school pupils

24 Oct 08

Pinsent Masons takes an unusual approach to corporate social responsibility

Graeme Henry joins HBJ Gateley Wareing

23 Oct 08

Corporate lawyer takes on new role as partner in firm's Edinburgh office

Law Society calls for more laws to be devolved to the Scottish Parliament

23 Oct 08

Calman Commission should consider more changes to legislation, says Society

Scottish homeowners should have more protection from repossession

23 Oct 08

Labour calls on Scottish Government to give Scots same protection and those in England and Wales

Government says no to commercial GPs

22 Oct 08

Consultation on preventing commercial companies running surgeries

Release dilemma as cancer attacks Lockerbie bomber

22 Oct 08

Megrahi said to have weeks rather than months to live

WS Society launches business skills programme

22 Oct 08

Aim to help young lawyers develop commercial and personal skills

First time buyers scheme extended

21 Oct 08

£60m to extend Open Market Shared Equity Pilot across Scotland

Reports show working of management of sex offenders

21 Oct 08

First reports under MAPPA scheme show offence and breach figures

Docherty to be new DKS

21 Oct 08

Bell & Scott partner takes over as Deputy Keeper of Signet in January

Career moves at two firms

20 Oct 08

Iain Smith Solicitors and Biggart Baillie announce appointments

Solicitors invited to work or study overseas

20 Oct 08

Thyne Scholarship looks at differences and similarities in legal systems

Royal assent gives three months to tighten health and safety

17 Oct 08

Jail terms more likely among increased penalties from January

Society confirms Pursuers’ Panel appointments

17 Oct 08

Six named to continue help against negligent solicitors

Edinburgh Council in bid to boost property market

17 Oct 08

"Economic resilience plan" includes mortgages and buying up new properties

Reforms bring big rise in bankruptcies

16 Oct 08

Second quarter figures show 70% increase on 2007

Lockerbie bomber granted right to full appeal

16 Oct 08

Judges agree defence team can argue all points

Lords committee presses for action on judicial independence

16 Oct 08

Ministerial Code should state clearly that criticism of decisions inappropriate

Mental health tribunal has new President

15 Oct 08

Lawyer and Dundee City councillor takes up new role

Call for evidence over additional support needs changes

15 Oct 08

Holyrood committee embarks on consultation over bill

42-day detention plan defeated

14 Oct 08

But Home Secretary says proposal will form a separate piece of legislation

Committee concern over plaques damages payments

13 Oct 08

Stage 1 report queries whether enough money to compensate asbestos victims

Law officers to join Faculty of Advocates

13 Oct 08

Lord Advocate and Solicitor General to be admitted on Dean's invitation

Fuel Poverty Forum calls for holistic approach

10 Oct 08

Significant investment needed if ministers to meet statutory target - report

Revenue offers grants for debt advice

10 Oct 08

Scottish charities invited to apply for next two years

Brussels Office seeks 09 trainees

10 Oct 08

Applications invited for trainees to undertake six-month secondments

Tartans register to become law

10 Oct 08

Member's bill passes final stage

Part time sheriff appointment

10 Oct 08

Advocate Lorna Drummond joins bench

Love letter causes sex offender entry

10 Oct 08

Questions over sex offence content of "breach of peace" letter

McGrigors makes four senior hires

9 Oct 08

Three solicitors and chief operating officer lured from rivals

Talks aim to bring Sharia courts to Scotland - report

9 Oct 08

Revelation that lawyers and Muslim groups in discussion with tribunal director

Elect prosecutors US-style, says think tank

9 Oct 08

Reform Scotland paper proposes non-political elections

More rights for additional support needs children

8 Oct 08

Out-of-area placing requests, and dispute mediation, to be introduced

Greenock's new fiscal is one of youngest

7 Oct 08

Laura McPherson (32) appointed district fiscal to Greenock and Rothesay

Government seeks to cut bureaucracy round child protection

7 Oct 08

Proposals aim to cut out multiple or unnecessary disclosure checks

Russell to head Judicial Appointments Board

7 Oct 08

University principal and former top civil servant takes over chair

Legal issues raised over drink pricing plan

6 Oct 08

Scottish ministers' proposals for minimum pricing come under critical scrutiny

Justice group calls for shakeup of tribunal system

6 Oct 08

Scottish tribunals at disadvantage, says steering group

Slate of promotions at Shepherd and Wedderburn

6 Oct 08

Eleven solicitors made up to associate

Law Society of Scotland names new chief executive

3 Oct 08

Lorna Jack of Scottish Development International to take over in January

Judicial Appointments Board has new member

3 Oct 08

Sheriff Kenneth Ross appointed in place of Sheriff Douglas Allan

Off-licence age proposal defeated, but SNP defiant

3 Oct 08

MSPs vote against move to raise legal purchase age to 21

Commissioner argues against underage sex provision

3 Oct 08

Criminalising young girls would put them off seeking medical advice, says Marshall

Government launches crofting proposals

2 Oct 08

Legal reforms would vary approach of Shucksmith Committee

Three new partners for Anderson Strathern

2 Oct 08

Katrina Lumsdaine, Susan MacLeod and James Blair take on new roles

COPFS launches new health and safety unit

2 Oct 08

Specialist division to investigate and prosecute health and safety breaches

Police did not have right to enter woman's home

2 Oct 08

Appeal court quashes conviction for obstruction of officers seeking to detain suspect

Flood bill comes before parliament

1 Oct 08

Bill promotes coordination of flood risk management

Solicitor charged with embezzlement

1 Oct 08

Valerie Macadam in court over alleged misappropriation of client money

Emergency would result in prisoner release

1 Oct 08

Scottish jails do not have capacity for loss of accommodation, warns SPS

Society restructures its complaints handling

1 Oct 08

System brought in line as Scottish Legal Complaints Commission opens its doors

News Library

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

FILLER_lawscotjobs (link opens in new window)