The Journal, September 2001, page 36
Remedies for domain name disputes are available under different branches of law. Here we consider only the law of passing off.
To establish passing off there must be (1) goodwill (2) a misrepresentation and (3) loss.
Goodwill has been defined as “the attractive force which brings in custom”. It is one of the significant assets of a successful business, capable of transfer and realisation. Goodwill may reside in the name or trading style of a business, its logos, badges, livery and even its address.
Typically a misrepresentation will involve one trader falsely representing that his goods or services are those of another. Equally, a false representation that another’s goods or services are yours, or that your goods or services are endorsed or licensed by or associated with another, or are of a particular quality or source, will involve misrepresentation. Crucially the misrepresentation must be such as to be likely to deceive the public.
The Courts have accepted that the law of passing off may be appropriate to provide a remedy in the case of domain name disputes.
In the well-known One in a Million1 case the Defendants had registered domain names incorporating the names of companies including Marks and Spencer, Sainsbury’s, Virgin and BT. The company had done nothing more than register the domain names. In the particular circumstances and taking account of the extent of the Plaintiffs’ reputation the Court granted an injunction inter alia on the ground of passing off.More recently in easyJet Airline Co. Ltd. and Ors v Tim Dainty2 summary judgment was granted in respect of the use of the domain name easyRealestate by the Defendant. In considering whether passing off was established the Court considered the content of the website to which the domain name was linked. This, it is suggested, is the correct approach. The website may state or otherwise make it obvious that no connection exists between the operators of the website and the company whose name has been usurped. In that event it may be difficult to establish passing off.
The Scottish courts, in a number of unreported cases3, have not hesitated to grant interim interdicts on an ex parte basis in domain name disputes, relying on passing off as the ground of action.
If you are instructed in a domain name dispute consider raising proceedings for interdict and interim interdict and damages.
The first difficulty you may have is identifying the Defenders. The offending webpages may not disclose the identity of the trader. In the case of domain names ending in .co.uk, you can use the WHOIS search facility on the Nominet site (www.nic.uk) to determine the identity of the registrant. In other cases you can search the BetterWhoIs site (www.betterwhois.com).
You need to aver the necessary elements for passing off:
The date on which your client’s business commenced trading or was incorporated, the history of use of the trading name or other insignia incorporated in the offending domain name, the goods or services in respect of which the name or insignia have been used will all be relevant.
Do they expressly state that the goods and services supplied are those of your client?
With this information to hand your preparations for an interim interdict hearing will be well underway.
Pauline McBride, pmb@bto.co.uk, Intellectual Property Consultancy, Brechin Tindal Oatts solicitors, www.bto.co.uk. Lisa and Pauline have represented clients involved in some of the earliest Scottish domain name litigations.
Current Issue FeaturesOn the scentInterview with Jane Irvine, Chair of the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission, on how the new body will operate and keep itself informed on legal practice Learning to live togetherA look at relations between the Law Society of England & Wales and its split-off bodies now dealing with professional regulation and complaints against solicitors Learning to live apartParenting classes for the newly separated, now common in the USA, are about to be trialled in Scotland, following a visit by Texan divorce coach Christina McGhee ARTL: one lender's viewMaking ARTL work; sites of special scientific interest; form 4 procedure Games without frontiersThe legal framework governing broadcasting rights for major sporting events, the prospects for change and the competing interests at stake Speaking up for childrenThe joint report by the four UK Children's Commissioners to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child provides a reality check for government and should dispel complacency Poor relations?Family businesses are feeling hard done by when it comes to finding professional advice that fully understands their needs, and are organising to press for action on training Justice for sale?Paper to a conference on delivering excellence in Scotland's civil justice system challenges the treatment of justice as a "commodity" Shining light into the darknessFirst of two articles on the Budget and Finance Bill explains the important changes in income tax, inheritance tax and capital gains tax Current Issue ArticlesCrunch timePresident's message: the Society is pressing for government action to mitigate the effects of the economic slowdown where it particularly hits solicitors' firms Home reports: oh no they won'tDefence of the author's views on home reports following previous replies Recoverable proceedsComment on part of the article "Dirty Money?", June 2008, p18 on recovering proceeds of crime Justice divertedOpinion that continued experience of summary justice diversion tends to contradict assertions that it is simply an efficient alternative to prosecution leading to a fine Legal aid review gets down to workSociety's letter to criminal practitioners on its work with the Scottish Government and others to monitor implementation of the summary legal aid changes CPD for new lawyersHow the Society is developing CPD training specifically for the needs of recently qualified solicitors Professional Practice CommitteeText of guideline on settlement by cheque, loan redemption and remit of the free proceeds of sale 2008 Time to sell up?Second and final part of the author's acocunt of lessons learnt from selling his legal practice: best strategies in concluding a sale, and how to prepare for what comes after Beyond chip and PINReport on a project which aims to guarantee the security of electronic signatures such as used in the ARTL system, for use in any legal transaction concluded over the internet Lender claimsWith a downturn in the property market increasing the risk of claims from lenders for losses suffered through mortgage default, the article examines how to minimise this The price of justiceLatest civil cases, including inordinate delay; third party notice; new defender; and three decisions on aspects of expenses Transition talesAnomalies and inconsistencies in practice under the new licensing regime would be greatly added to if some of the latest government proposals come to pass Falling between stoolsCourt rules place unnecessary obstacles in the way of separating cohabitants who wish to make a counter application for financial provision The Environment v XRegulations are pending that will introduce new duties to avoid, or remedy, damage to the environment - and it can sue More equal than others?Two English cases appear to settle the question of which creditors are entitled to share under the new "prescribed part" provisions Points to proveThe next phase of the points-based immigration system will come into force shortly, with the rules applying to skilled workers with a job offer Website reviewsReviews of sites covering news of matters relating to Scots law and lawyers Book reviewsReviews of Gloag & Henderson (12th ed); Evidence (Davidson) Whose star will shine?In-house lawyers have the chance to see their unique talents recognised through the latest expansion of The Signet Accreditation Taken for grantedThe Society has issued advice to in-house lawyers over the granting of a non domino dispositions in favour of their employers An A to G of EPCsWith energy performance certificates about to arrive across the property market, the author explains what they require, and some issues they raise particularly in letting |