Routes to qualification: the Italian picture

An Italian lawyer with an interest in training in different jurisdictions reports on current developments in the Italian legal system

Submission, 8 February 2007

---

As a keen observer of the development of legal professions in different European countries, I have found information on the current consultation going on in Scotland extremely interesting. The review of training and standards in the profession and for those seeking appropriate qualifications is a corner stone of every country's legal professional system.

The same issue has been and is still currently discussed in Italy, where the new executive is continuing a process which began several years ago, bringing to parliamentary discussion new hypotheses of reform. The aim is ambitious: to modernise the whole legal system and grant wider access to the legal professions, removing artificial and unreasonable barriers

This effort of reform and modernisation has had a different effect on the main three Italian professional bodies for legal professions.

What follows is a loose description of these current developments in the legal professions in Italy. The work is intended as an appendix - small and modest - of the very interesting work of Michael Torrance and Michael J Robertson published in the Journal, December 2006, 15 (http://www.journalonline.co.uk/article/1003675.aspx), and as a contribution to the current discussion taking place in Scotland.

Overview

There are three legal professions in Italy, all requiring a degree in law for entry to each profession:

- avvocato (lawyer);

- notaio (notary);

- consulente del lavoro (employment law consultant).

Three independent professional bodies rule the three professions:

- Ordine degli avvocati;

- Ordine dei notai;

- Ordine dei consulenti del lavoro

Each professional body fully independently oversees the training period, acts as a discipline tribunal, issues guidelines and good practice instructions. This independence is limited only by national law and by the right of trainees, legal practitioners and those making complaints to appeal to the Tribunale Amministrativo Regionale (Regional Administrative Court), the legal professions' decision-making tribunal.

Route to qualification

The prospective avvocato (lawyer) must undertake un Corso di Laurea specialistica in Legge (a full degree in law), which requires five years of study. After obtaining la Laurea, the future avvocato must look for a lawyer willing to become his mentor (his dominus) to start the training period (the tirocinio). The tirocinio requires two years of practical and theoretical training, assisting the practitioner in the office and in court.

During the training period the trainee (the discipulus) must assist his mentor in at least 20 hearings each semester (80 hearings in two years).

The aspiring lawyer must also produce, for the professional body, several studies and works related to the cases discussed with the practitioner.

After completing the training period and receiving the professional body's approval, the lawyer sits a state examination comprising written and oral tests. Success in the examination gives admittance to the profession.

After completing the first year of training, the future lawyer may also submit a request to the professional body to practise in court to defend in minor cases during his training period. The trainee may also replace one year of training with the undertaking of a post-degree academic course: the Scuola Superiore per le professioni legali.

How the training is viewed

Legal training in Italy is generally seen as efficient and as a successful balance between the previous academic background of the prospective lawyer and the experience he/she gains during the two-year period.

A major drawback of the Italian system was the ever increasing number of aspiring lawyers. A great number of lawyers complained and are still complaining, asking for major controls over the number of new trainees, assuming that an uncontrolled increase would reduce the quality of the service. From the other side, the aspiring lawyers find more and more difficulties in undertaking the training period, having to rely more on personal contacts and connections than on their effective skills and capacities in seeking their mentor.

The establishment of the Scuola Superiore per le professioni legali can be seen as an attempt to grant wider access to the profession.

An equal and meritocratic selection: two different routes

The access requirements to the other two legal professions (notary and employment law consultant) are similar, with minor differences, granting a more equal and meritocratic method of selection.

Prospective notaries, after obtaining the degree, must undertake a training period in a notary's office to sit the state examination. The only difference is that the state examination for notary does not give admittance to the profession to all the applicants who pass the written and oral tests, but only to the best ones. In fact the Ministero della Giustizia (the Minister of Justice) annually fixes the number of new notaries admitted to the profession, so that only the best examinees enter.

A different path to the profession has been established for the aspiring employment law consultants, with the dual purpose of controlling the number of applicants graduating annually to the profession and secondly to grant a better quality of service offered to the public.

As a result of an agreement between the professional body of employment law consultants and the most prestigious Italian universities, a brand new degree has recently emerged, specifically designed for students aiming to become employment law consultants. After obtaining the degree the applicants will undertake a two-year training period.

This first strong synergy between the universities and the professional body has produced concrete results, providing the aspiring employment law consultants with more focused academic instruction, so that during the subsequent training period, the future consultants, having acquired a better theoretical knowledge and understanding of the profession, can turn their attention to more practical matters.

Synergy: the “new philosophy”

The recent experience described above has given birth to a new powerful philosophy (for trainees and for practitioners) based on a common effort to improve the quality and knowledge in the legal professions, involving all the different components of the Italian legal world.

The academic and the judiciary systems, the public administration, the lawyers, the notaries, the consultants and their associations and professional bodies are slowly converging at a common focal point with the aim of building a permanent exchange-system of theoretical and practical legal knowledge and experience.

This system is considered the only useful mechanism for the necessary modernisation and updating of the whole legal world, including access to the professions. A new path for the legal world which, as happens in many more scientific fields, should also have a European and international development.

Eugenio D'Urso, Manager for Contracts and Legal Services, Council of Capannori, Lucca, Tuscany, Italy

Current Submissions 04.07.08 Getting a Get in Scotland - 2 This follow-up to the article published in March 2006 explains how current Scots divorce law affects Jewish clients and how solicitors can give appropriate advice 12.06.08 No place for secrecy Fuller version of the Opinion article, Journal, June 2008: critique of the system for appointment as Queen’s Counsel in Scotland 11.03.08 One Scotland, many cultures? Despite the protections of the Human Rights Act, the position of travelling people in Scotland appears to have worsened in recent years - why? 26.02.08 Bank charges and the Unfair Terms Regulations The significance of the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations in the context of the current litigation over bank charges 21.02.08 CGT: Don't lose out on 6 April 2008 Couples should consider asset transfers before then to preserve indexation relief 14.12.07 Common sense prevails The options open, and the issues that arise, now that the proposed planning gain supplement is not to be introduced 07.12.07 Discounting justice Author contends that sentencing discounts and other developments have created an imbalance in the justice system 10.10.07 Advocacy in mediation An overview of the mediation process and the opportunities for solicitors and clients 06.09.07 TUPE: stay your hand A Court of Session ruling on a law firm redundancy marks a fundamental change in TUPE 24.07.07 EAT breaks ground with TUPE insolvency ruling Ruling on when insolvency proceedings begin leaves successor employer liable 06.07.07 Confidentiality clauses - beware! The Information Commissioner's decision in the VisitScotland case requires very careful drafting of confidentiality provisions in public sector contracts if they are to work 06.07.07 The power of marks: Frankie goes after Hollys name How failure to address issues of ownership of the band's name stored up trouble for Frankie Goes to Hollywood 14.05.07 Court plans with little appeal The fuller version of the Opinion article in the Journal for May 2007 14.05.07 Winning ways The fuller version of the article in the Journal for May 2007 08.02.07 Routes to qualification: the Italian picture An Italian lawyer with an interest in training in different jurisdictions reports on current developments in the Italian legal system 09.01.07 Contractual handcuffs: enhanced redundancy rights The Court of Appeal decision in Keeley v FOSROC International Ltd requires employers to exercise caution when referring to redundancy rights in staff handbooks 27.12.06 The Isle of Man An summary of the current legal and tax regime for individuals and companies based on the island (a longer version of the briefing in the November 2006 issue) 15.11.06 Costume Wars: copyright storm over the troopers A row over "Star Wars" costumes illustrates the need to protect all intellectual property rights in written agreements 13.10.06 Survival of the fittest? A reply Reply to article on selection for Diploma and traineeship places by Michael Torrance in the September 2006 Journal 13.10.06 TUPE passes the buck Far from providing clarity, the new regulations will need litigation to decide the effect of the insolvency provisions (longer version of October 2006 briefing article) 17.08.06 For supplement read tax - an update Authors update their previous Journal article on the proposed planning gain supplement 17.08.06 Technology and the Scottish courts An update on the use of technology in the Scottish courts, based on the author's experience of a recent patent case 26.07.06 A lack of trust Forthcoming in August issue, put online because of its urgency, the article outlines the final form of the trust tax changes in this year's Finance Act 17.07.06 Ireland 4, Italy 0 The ECJ decision in the Irish-Italian dispute in the Parmalat companies liquidation proceedings provides important guidance on jurisdiction 05.04.06 Legal science or law-lite? A response This reply to Professor Gretton argues that changes in Scots law teaching are a necessary response to changes in universities, the wider community and the law itself 03.04.06 Opening a binding global route for personal data In a significant move the Information Commissioner has allowed a company to transfer employees' personal data outwith the EU under binding internal rules 02.04.06 Mentally disordered offenders Overview of the options available to the courts when dealing with offenders who have or may have a mental disorder, following recent legislative reforms 30.03.06 Bias and mental health tribunals: a reply Reply to criticisms of the new tribunals, arguing that the composition of the tribunals is not inherently unfair and only research can assess their performance 17.01.06 Legal aid in children's hearing referrals This paper delivered at the legal aid conference, argues that the interests of justice require better remuneration for solicitors appearing in children's hearing cases 09.12.05 Holes in Scotland's corporate killing proposals Gaps in the expert working group's proposals could make them unworkable and bad for business 10.08.05 Prosecuting bigotry offences Two appeal decisions have exposed limitations in the statutory offences directed at racial abuse 08.07.05 Commissioner: Public Authorities must do more Information Commissioner's first appeal decision highlights areas for improvement 14.04.05 New identity for criminal justice body Scottish Association for the Study of Offending launches by removing "Delinquency" from title 14.04.05 Information and Consultation Regulations Briefing on the regulations in force from 6 April 2005, covering businesses with more than the prescribed number of employees 13.04.05 Retailers seek effective court action on crime Scottish Retail Consortium proposes more effective intervention following 3rd Retail Crime Survey 11.04.05 Appropriate dispute resolution This paper, given to the Four Jurisdictions Conference in Nice this year, discusses how family law can make a difference for the better by careful choice of the most suitable method of resolution 09.03.05 ASBOs and young people What to look for when acting for a young person facing an antisocial behaviour order application 21.02.05 Sell or transfer? Longer version of briefing published in February 2005 issue, page 44 08.02.05 Promoting competitiveness or competition? Discussion of EU rules on state aids with particular reference to Highlands and Islands ferries 10.11.04 Guarding the inner sanctum How to minimise the risk of breaches of internet security 10.11.04 The Clinical Trials Directive - a summary What the EU Clinical Trials Directive means for trials of medicinal products 13.10.04 Sheriff Court Rules Council consultation paper Consultation on proposals for further extension of the use of information technology in civil cases in the sheriff court (response date: 15 November 2004) 13.10.04 Ignorantia juris: it's all Greek to me Second annual APEX lecture given by the President of the Law Society of Scotland, on the rule of law and its essential components 13.10.04 Virtual firms: transactional learning on the web How today's Diploma students are introduced to legal transactions in a virtual environment 13.10.04 Drafting consumer contracts Guidance on drafting consumer contracts and ensuring compliance with the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999