Privy Council raises appeal hopes

Decision on Crown disclosure could impact on appeals of notorious criminals


The Privy Council has quashed the convictions of two Scots who claimed the Crown failed to disclose vital documents and information about witnesses before and during the trials.

The judges ruled that the trials of James Holland, who was convicted of two charges of assault and robbery, and Alvin Lee Sinclair, convicted of assault to severe injury, were in breach of article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the right to a fair trial.

Holland had appealed on the ground that the Crown had used a witness to identify him in the dock, despite having failed to do so in a police parade. In addition, outstanding criminal charges aganist witnesses had not been disclosed. Sinclair complained that the Crown had failed to disclose a police statement that was inconsistent with evidence the witness gave in court.

To date the disclosure of Crown evidence or information has rested on the practice of the Lord Advocate and Crown Office. In future however, unless there are national security implications, all statements will have to be made available "as a matter of course".

The ruling could have implications for the appeals of some of Scotland's most notorious murderers. The appeals of William Beggs, the limbs in the loch murderer, Nat Fraser who was convicted of his murdering his wife Arlene and Luke Mitchell, convicted of killing Jodi Jones, could all be affected by the judgment because of lack of disclosure and/or reliance on dock identification. Even Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al Megrahi, convicted of the Lockerbie bombing, may found on the ruling.

The judgments can be accessed through the links under the Devolution Cases heading at http://www.privy-council.org.uk/output/Page495.asp .

LAW SOCIETY - EMPLOYMENT LAW Search companies online Click here for full details visit our website LAW SOCIETY - HOME REPORTS Click SLAB Click for full details click here to get int touch Events

Current News

PM changes tack on tax-raising powers

Allowing Scottish Parliament more accountability would strengthen the UK, says Brown

Summary justice reform success, claims Angiolini

Lord Advocate's letter says figures to date indicate new system working

Advocates in Aberdeen launch new website

Internet presence aimed at increasing awareness of Society of Advocates in the north east

Legal profession, local income tax top bill list

Scottish Government unveils legislative programme for 2008-09

Step up to associate for Fife lawyer

Sue Arrowsmith promoted at Murray Donald Drummond Cook LLP

Prosecution inspectorate publishes annual report

Review pending of new fiscal fine system

Society welcomes Legal Profession Bill

Hopes that bill will provide for alternative business structures for law firms

'No proof that plaques harmful': insurance lawyers

Industry's legal team argue against proposed law extending compensation

Commissioner orders release of tender information

Council not justified in claim that Street Outreach documents must be kept secret

Stamp duty break for lower value properties

12-month threshold of £175,000 among government moves to buck up housing market

Government publishes sentencing proposals

Judges and sheriffs would need to reveal reasons for departing from guidelines

Revenue reminds of new tax return date

31 October now deadline for paper returns

Blackadders' review results in 44 job losses

Two branches also close as firm consolidates to combat property market troubles

Area procurator fiscal appointment for Central

Michelle Macleod takes on new role

Partner catch for Ledingham Chalmers

Neil Anderson appointed, while Marysia Lewis takes up floating sheriff appointment