Another sheriff criticises summary choice

PC who torched his car spared "no purpose" jail term

News, 17 March 2006

---

A second sheriff has criticised the prosecution of a case under summary procedure because the maximum prison term he could impose fell far short of what he thought appropriate.

Sheriff Craig Caldwell declined to impose a custodial sentence on PC Alan Gavin, 43, who was found guilty last month of defrauding his insurance company and wasting police time after having his car towed to a local joyriders' haunt and set on fire beore claiming it had been stolen. The trial had heard how the car needed a repair that Gavin could not afford.

The sheriff said that as Gavin was a first offender, the most he could impose under summary procedure was three months, which would mean Gavin would be out in six weeks. He added: "I see no purpose in that whatsoever." If the case had been prosecuted before a jury, he said, the sentence would have been two or three years.

Yesterday Sheriff Michael Fletcher was reported as making similar remarks in the case of a man who carried out a series of frauds against local businesses.

A Crown Office spokesperson said that prosecution decisions were never taken lightly and always in the public interest. In each case the sheriff could have imposed a prison term but had chosen not to.

Current News 29.08.08 No compensation culture in UK - survey Accident helpline reveals most Brits won't and don't make spurious claims 29.08.08 Commission plan to end inconsistent sentencing Proposal imminent for creation of Sentencing Commission 29.08.08 OU course teaches more about the law New course aims to give people a better understanding of Scotland's legal processes 28.08.08 Auditor of Court appointed Kenneth Cumming to take over from Neil Crichton at the Court of Session 28.08.08 Education advocacy services given government cash Funding for children's additional support needs advocacy 28.08.08 North move for private client specialist Mark Stewart joins Aberdeen firm Stronachs as a partner 28.08.08 Database of domestic abusers needed HMIC recommends Scottish police forces adopt common practices and processes 27.08.08 Shared equity scheme details out New supply shared equity intended to help people on low incomes get on housing ladder 27.08.08 Prison population hits record levels More than 8,000 people now locked up; SPS says it can contain but not provide services 26.08.08 Concerns over mortgage requirement change Society says revised new-build instructions to solicitors not appropriate for Scots market 26.08.08 MSP proposes equity fines for companies Owners should be accountable for health and safety breaches, says SNP's Wilson 25.08.08 Legislation needed for land management row Home owners should not be locked in to manintenance agreements, says MP 25.08.08 Special meeting backs Society's strategy Review group the way to keep up pressure on legal aid, solicitors agree 25.08.08 Eight Scottish law firms in UK top 100 Magazine survey rates firms according to turnover for last year